Tax tool shows whether you may pay a marriage penalty

For some couples, first comes love, then comes marriage – and then comes a higher tax bill.

For others, it’s love, marriage and then nice little gift from Uncle Sam: Lower taxes than if each person were single.

A new tool from the Tax Policy Center lets you find out whether you and your spouse could be subject to what’s called the “marriage penalty” – a quirk in our complicated tax laws that results in some married couples paying more in taxes than if they were single.

Roberton Williams, a senior fellow with the Tax Policy Center, said his previous research has shown that more taxpayers get a tax benefit from being married than pay a tax penalty.

He suspects that trend has moved even further in favor of married couples getting tax benefits in recent years, because of tax cuts enacted during the Bush Administration that are still in effect today.

Nevertheless, some couples do end up paying more taxes than before they were married.

A couple with high earnings could be pushed into a higher tax bracket than if they were filing alone under the new laws passed as part of the fiscal cliff deal, which put the highest tax bracket at $400,000 for individuals and $450,000 for married couples.

But Williams said low-income families can actually end up being hit hardest by the marriage penalty. That’s because major tax breaks designed to encourage people to work phase out as incomes go up.

For example, a single mom two kids under 13 making $10,000 a year could lose out on a lot of potential tax breaks if she marries someone with an income of about $30,000 a year. Using the Tax Policy Center’s calculator, a couple in that situation would pay a marriage penalty of more than $1,000, assuming no other deductions.

On the other hand, a family with two kids under 13 in which one spouse makes $100,000 a year and the other makes $20,000 would see a tax benefit from being married. According to the Tax Policy Center’s calculator, that couple would see a bonus of more than $400, also assuming no other deductions.

If you do end up paying a tax penalty, you can to take comfort in the fact that the financial gains are likely to outweigh the losses in the long run. Other research has shown that people who get and stay married tend to be wealthier than those who stay single or get divorced.

Want to see if you’ll get a tax bonus or a penalty? Check out the marriage penalty calculator.

Related: Here's how we want Uncle Sam to spend our tax dollars

 

People.com
5297,5

Discuss this post

The low income person would NOT be missing out on tax breaks that are designed for the poor, as the earned income credit can't be used when filing married and separate. I am mostly a stay-at-home dad with a small stream of personal income. The tool stated my wife and I were being paying way more filing jointly, the sole reason being they said I was missing the EITC (which I would not be able to use regardless).

Maybe I am looking at it wrongly.

    Reply#1 - Thu Feb 14, 2013 11:20 AM EST

    yet if you are not married and have no job and 5 kids you can get 1000' s back as long as you are a mexican in the USA illegally and file your tax return. thanks to Obama.

    • 1 vote
    Reply#2 - Thu Feb 14, 2013 3:06 PM EST

    Ironically I asked my CPA last week: would I get the same refund if I was married and filing jointly (as compared to my current single filing). His answer: I would lose $2,000 in refund. So, guess the IRS is anti-marriage, at least in my situation. How am I going to break this news to the little lady?

      Reply#3 - Thu Feb 14, 2013 4:16 PM EST
      You're in Easy Mode. If you prefer, you can use XHTML Mode instead.
      As a new user, you may notice a few temporary content restrictions. Click here for more info.