'As long as you're up there ...' -- home remodel don'ts

Plan on making a few updates to spiff up the house? Keep the "few" in mind.

 Two demons wait for unsuspecting homeowners, hoping for their chance to gobble up time and money on new home and remodeling projects. The are called The Ripple Effect and Project Creep.

  • The Ripple Effect lurks quietly in the background. Just like the movements on the pond surface for which it's named, The Ripple Effect starts out small and grows, expanding until it engulfs the entire project.
  • Project Creep is a silent menace, staying out of sight until it's too late to avoid and putting the whole job at risk.

The Ripple Effect is the remodeling budget's worst enemy and can wreak havoc on small and large projects alike.

A window replacement is a simple, isolated project, right? But the interior and exterior trim must be replaced and painted, and the exterior siding may have to be reworked, especially if the new window isn't the same size as the old one.

And that's just the beginning. Once that window is replaced and the new window trim painted, the rest of the trim in the room looks bad by comparison, and so you decide to paint that, too. A pebble has been dropped in the pond, and the ripples have begun to spread.

What started out as a simple window replacement ends up as the refinishing of an entire room.

In new home projects, The Ripple Effect is more pronounced in open plan designs. With fewer walls to separate spaces, it's difficult to make flooring transitions from one room to another so more expensive flooring materials often cover more of the house. The lack of interior walls also requires a more expensive structural system and makes the placement of duct work and plumbing more difficult.

Don't Make Waves

But The Ripple Effect can be controlled if you take a moment to consider the impact one project can have on other parts of the house. The root of the problem in the window replacement example is that a new standard-sized window won't exactly fit the existing opening, necessitating the replacement of the trim.

But a custom-sized window, carefully installed, might allow you to reinstall the existing trim inside and outside, and avoid The Ripple Effect entirely. Sure, you'll spend more on the window, but you'll save everywhere else and avoid The Ripple Effect.

And in a new home project, careful planning of the room layouts and space adjacencies allows flooring and other finishes to "break" where you want them to.

 Project Creep

Project Creep is a close cousin to The Ripple Effect. Project Creep happens when the extent of the work begins to grow, creeping along at first, until no one seems able to control the spiraling costs.

Older homes, for example, often require building code upgrades when they're remodeled — upgrades that may have little to do with the project itself. When structural loads are changed in any way, for example, the existing structure must be rebuilt or retrofitted to meet updated code requirements. And moving structure usually means reworking the wiring, duct work and plumbing that's been routed through the area.

Project Creep can attack new home projects, too. Sometimes the causes are almost impossible to predict, such as when the excavation of the site uncovers poor soil conditions. Sometimes the cause is an outside force — an architectural review board, for example. But mostly, Project Creep is a result of a difference in expectations between homeowner, builder and architect.

Plan ahead to avoid Ripple and Creep

On any project, start with a clear idea of the level of finish and quality you expect. Don't assume that the architect and builder are in tune with your ideas about finishes. Discuss your expectations in detail and, whenever possible, see the actual finishes and fixtures.

If you're not the detail-oriented type, hire a professional interior designer.

Poor quality drawings cause additional unplanned work during construction and always end up costing homeowners money and time. My firm has been hired many times to correct drawings done elsewhere that contained glaring errors, omitted necessary structural steel or just plain didn't work.

Sloppy drawings are an open invitation to Project Creep

On a remodeling or room addition project, evaluate the feasibility of the project in terms of the impact it will have on parts of the home that you're not intending to remodel. Often, room additions can easily be designed to minimize the effect on the existing structure.

Finally, always have realistic expectations about your project budget and communicate that budget to your architect and builder. When everyone understands the project's financial goals, the chances for success are greatly increased.

Related:

Richard Taylor is a residential architect based in Dublin, Ohio and is a contributor to Zillow Blog. Connect with him at http://www.rtastudio.com/index.htm.

Note: The views and opinions expressed in this article are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the opinion or position of Zillow.

 

People.com
5297,5

Discuss this post

The motto of construction is "Don't worry I can fix that". As an example, it's the response to your saying "that door's not level".

    Reply#1 - Sun Jun 17, 2012 11:53 AM EDT

    I recently went through the "ripple effect" (and still going through it). My wife and I decided we wanted a new stove and over-the-range microwave. It turned into a completely brand new kitchen, down to replacing the drywall and floor, cabinets etc. Oh... it doesn't stop there. Since our subfloor/joists are not adequate to handle tile, we decided to put in hardwood flooring which means I'm going to have to rip up the old hardwood in the adjacent rooms and basically redo the entire floor/level. Fortunately I can do all of this myself which is saving me thousands but still... Its like the 80's movie "The Money Pit". Where are House Crashers and Holmes on Homes when I need them!? ;-)

    • 2 votes
    Reply#2 - Sun Jun 17, 2012 1:10 PM EDT

    Yup. Would love to replace my kitchen's countertop, but if I do, then the old top will have to be ripped, then the walls will have to be refinished, if wall needs refinishing then the cabinets have to come off. Hah! Not retiring here, so letting next owner do his way.

      Reply#3 - Sun Jun 17, 2012 1:16 PM EDT

      If you are building a custom home, measure, measure and measure. Measure the rooms in your current house, model homes, even your friends' homes. When you get your drawings, pay very close attention. We recently built a very expensive custom home. We questioned the size of the bathrooms, but the architect assured us that they would be fine. He is a small person, short and slight. Our family members are not small and slight. In fact, several are the size of pro football players. The bathrooms are WAY to small for comfort. Yes, this allows the bedrooms to be bigger, but you do need room to dry yourself and put on a robe without knocking everything off the counter and shelves in the bathroom. In fact, the builder had to search for a toilet for one of the bathrooms that was small enough not to be hit when the door was opened. Keep your measuring tape handy when the house is being framed! Know how big a toilet, sink, regular bathtub, etc. is, otherwise you will end up with 'miniatures.'

        Reply#4 - Sun Jun 17, 2012 1:24 PM EDT

        Also check your state for your local "Home Performance with Energy Star" program. It helps to get a road map if you plan on stating home improvements and access your state's energy Efficiency Program. Low Interest Financing, Equipment/Appliance Rebates and other incentives might be available if you take a few moment to explore ahead of time.

        Do your homework and you might just be able to find ways to help with the cost.

        Many of these program do a home energy assessment to help you determine area in your home that could use help. Many times you are working with a third party assessor who's job is not dependent on making a sale and does the type of assessments you see being done by Mike Holmes.

          Reply#5 - Sun Jun 17, 2012 5:14 PM EDT

          Had my home built in 2000 . After 20 yrs of the wife and i dreaming and planning . Now i can honestly say i would not change a thing. Were never moving again and our home is not for sale. :-)

          I almost forgot the best part our mortgage is paid in full.

          • 2 votes
          Reply#6 - Sun Jun 17, 2012 7:41 PM EDT

          "Striving to better, oft we mar that which is well' or as a surgeon once commented "the enemy of good is better".

            Reply#7 - Sun Jun 17, 2012 10:11 PM EDT

            Thirty years without a dishwasher or garbage disposal until I could afford to rip out the entire kitchen. Took 4 months of planning and purchasing. The kitchen was ripped out and replaced within 2 weeks including electrical, plumbing, new cabinets, counters and flooring. All under budget. You should have seen my project plan! Worked great.

            • 2 votes
            Reply#8 - Mon Jun 18, 2012 12:42 AM EDT

            "Project Creep" That is a great way to describe what we often see with homeowners beginning home improvement project. A great way to avoid this is to deal directly with contractors and MAKE SURE that all terms and conditions are spelled out, that way you know exactly what is your responsibility and there are no surprises.

              Reply#10 - Tue Jun 26, 2012 2:14 PM EDT
              You're in Easy Mode. If you prefer, you can use XHTML Mode instead.
              As a new user, you may notice a few temporary content restrictions. Click here for more info.