John Schoen: Why a McDonald's job often beats jobless benefits

TODAY Money expert and msnbc.com senior writer John Schoen chatted live with TODAYshow.com readers on Monday afternoon about this morning's jobs report and employment prospects.

Here are two of his answers and a complete archive.

Question from Jordan:
I am 16 and from Michigan. I would like some ideas on what someone my age should do for making money.

Answer from John:
It's really tough as the jobless rate for teenagers (aged 16 through 19) is 25 percent. But that doesn't mean you can't find ways to make money. Some teenagers turn a hobby into a business, like selling things on eBay. Where I live, it's been a great winter for high school kids who shovel driveways. If you put your mind to it, there are opportunities out there. But you may have an easier time making your own job rather than looking for someone else to hire you.

Question from Dennis:
I am trying to decide if I should take a job at McDonalds or collect unemployment. Since they both pay the same, what should I do?

Answer from John:
The point I think you're trying to make here - that jobless benefits discourage people from working - is the subject of much debate among economists and politicians every time the extended benefits come up for renewal.

My personal opinion is that, while three may be cases of people collecting benefits who could get a job, that number is small. Most unemployed people want to work and can't find jobs. If they were simply kicking back and collecting benefits, why are there five unemployed workers for every job opening?

Complete archive:

If you have a question for our TODAY Money experts, submit it here.

To sign up for an e-mail reminder for our next chat, click here.

People.com
5297,5

Discuss this post

You take what ever job you can. Unemployment is not a time for vacation or free money. You take the job because it show future employers that you are a capable and able body. It also looks better on your job application and resume when you show no extended breaks in your work record. You also take what ever job you can get because you never know where this job may take you. The longer you are out of work, the harder it will be for you to get back into the work force and you probably will not like working any job you were to get good or bad. Unemployment is not forever and it definitely should not be for 99 weeks.

    Reply#1 - Sat Feb 5, 2011 3:26 PM EST
    You're in Easy Mode. If you prefer, you can use XHTML Mode instead.
    As a new user, you may notice a few temporary content restrictions. Click here for more info.